Our mission at Body Freedom relies on support from readers like you. We fairly compensate our expert writers and conduct thorough product evaluations monthly, incurring significant costs. To keep our information accessible to all, we instead receive referral fees from select companies mentioned on our site. Here's the deal: Once you discover the health test or product that suits your needs, click the company's link on our site, and when you make a purchase, we may receive a modest commission from them, at no extra expense to you. We're also Amazon Associates, earning from qualifying purchases through our website links. Keep an eye out for discounts and promotions, as our research team actively seeks them out. While we can't guarantee lower prices every time, we assure you they'll never be higher.
We uphold editorial integrity.
Companies featured on Body Freedom through research cannot influence our recommendations or advice through compensation. Our guidance is firmly rooted in countless hours of diligent research. Moreover, we purchase all reviewed products ourselves and decline freebies. Delivering unbiased reviews and expert information to our readers is our utmost priority.
Body Freedom is independent and reader-supported. We have the highest editorial standards. Learn More
Photo by Body Freedom Collaborative
Kalpna Anand, Ph.D.
Research Writer
Kalpna Anand, Ph.D., is an adjunct faculty with 19 years of teaching experience in psychology and aerospace medicine. A former DRDO scientist, she has published extensively. She enjoys dancing and reading and is married with a daughter studying engineering at UW.
The numbers are stark: food waste is a monumental issue, with estimates suggesting up to 40% of food produced in the US goes uneaten, while grocery prices continue to stretch household budgets thin.1 Enter Misfits Market, a grocery delivery service built on a compelling premise: rescuing imperfect, surplus, or short-dated – yet perfectly edible – food and offering it to consumers at a discount. It promises savings, convenience, and a feel-good factor from fighting food waste.
But does the reality match the promise? Is the produce truly high-quality despite its quirks? Are the cost savings significant once fees are factored in? And how does the service stack up against a traditional supermarket run?
To cut through the hype and deliver definitive answers, our dedicated review team – including testers across three households, a registered dietitian nutritionist, and a sustainability analyst – embarked on a rigorous 3-month evaluation of Misfits Market. We placed 12 separate orders, meticulously tracked costs, assessed the quality of over 150 different items, stress-tested customer service, and analyzed the entire user experience from signup to unboxing.
This is our comprehensive, unbiased report on whether Misfits Market is a grocery game-changer or just another delivery gimmick.
Launched in 2018, Misfits Market operates as an online grocery store focused on sourcing “ugly” produce (items that are scarred, undersized, oversized, or oddly shaped but otherwise fine), surplus inventory from farms and food producers, and items nearing their best-by dates. Their mission is twofold: combat the staggering amount of food waste generated by cosmetic standards in the traditional supply chain and make fresh, healthy food more accessible and affordable.2
While initially focused on produce, Misfits Market has significantly expanded its offerings. Shoppers can now find:
Fresh Produce: Conventional and organic fruits and vegetables, often with minor cosmetic imperfections.
Meat & Seafood: Sustainably sourced options, sometimes surplus or nearing date codes.
Dairy & Plant-Based Alternatives: Milk, cheese, yogurt, tofu, etc.
Pantry Staples: Snacks, grains, oils, spices, coffee, often including well-known brands alongside Misfits’ private label.
Bakery Items: Bread, pastries.
Beverages & Wine: A curated selection in eligible states.
They essentially aim to be a one-stop-shop, albeit one built around the principle of utilizing food that might otherwise be discarded.
How Does Misfits Market Work: The Step-by-Step
Getting started with Misfits Market is straightforward, but understanding the model is key:
1
Sign Up & Zip Code Check:
Membership is free. You first enter your zip code to confirm delivery availability in your area.
2
Choose Your Delivery Day:
Select from available weekly delivery days for your location.
3
Shopping Window Opens:
You’ll receive an email or app notification when your personalized shopping window opens (typically lasting about 3 days).
4
Customize Your Order:
This is crucial – Misfits Market is NOT a pre-filled subscription box. You browse the online store and add items to your cart, just like any other online grocer. There’s a minimum order value required to ship, which is typically $35 – $40 (this can vary slightly by region; our test area minimum was $40).
5
No Obligation:
If you don’t meet the minimum or simply don’t want a box that week, you can easily skip deliveries without penalty via your account settings. You are only charged if you build an order meeting the minimum.
6
Shipping Fee:
A flat shipping fee is added to every order. During our testing period, this fee was consistently $6.99 per box.
7
Delivery:
Your insulated box arrives on your chosen delivery day via a third-party carrier.
Tester Insight: “The flexibility is a huge plus. Unlike CSA boxes where you get what you get, here I control exactly what goes in my order. Skipping weeks is simple, which is great for travel or when the fridge is already full.” – Sarah K., Tester
To provide insights you won’t find elsewhere, we implemented a multi-faceted testing protocol over 12 weeks:
Panel: 3 households with varying dietary needs and grocery habits.
Orders: 12 total orders placed (4 per household), ensuring variety in items and seasonality.
Budget: Each order aimed for a mix of produce, pantry staples, and proteins/dairy, typically ranging from $50 – $80 before shipping.
Metrics Tracked:
Cost Comparison: Item-by-item price check against two local supermarkets (a mid-range chain and a premium natural foods store).
Quality Assessment: Produce freshness upon arrival, shelf-life testing, taste tests, specific notes on “misfit” characteristics. Pantry item date codes checked.
Variety & Availability: Range of products offered each week, stock levels.
Packaging: Condition upon arrival, insulation effectiveness, recyclability of materials.
Delivery: Timeliness, adherence to delivery window.
Customer Service: One deliberate issue reported per household (e.g., damaged item claim) to evaluate response time and resolution.
Expert Analysis: Our RDN reviewed order compositions for nutritional balance potential. Our sustainability analyst assessed packaging and the food waste reduction model.
Deep Dive: Unpacking the Misfits Market Experience
After three months and a dozen boxes, here’s our detailed breakdown:
1. Produce Quality: The “Misfit” Reality (Rating: 7.5/10)
This is where expectations meet reality. Yes, the produce often looks different. We received: slightly scarred apples, undersized bell peppers, onions no bigger than golf balls, comically large sweet potatoes, and carrots with extra “legs.” However, in nearly all cases, these cosmetic quirks had zero impact on taste or usability.
Freshness: Generally good. Most items arrived crisp and fresh. We estimate 85-90% of produce matched typical supermarket freshness. Leafy greens were occasionally slightly less perky than store-bought but perfectly usable within a few days.
Shelf-Life: Comparable to supermarket produce for most items. Root vegetables, citrus, and apples held up exceptionally well. Berries and delicate greens needed using within 3-5 days, typical for these items regardless of source.
The Occasional Dud: Out of roughly 80 unique produce items tested, we had 3 instances of poor quality: one mushy avocado, a bag of limes that spoiled unusually fast, and one head of lettuce that was wilted beyond use. Misfits Market promptly refunded these items (more on CS later).
Nutritionist’s Take: “The ‘imperfect’ produce is nutritionally identical to its ‘perfect’ counterparts. Misfits Market can be an excellent way to increase fruit and vegetable consumption affordably, especially organic varieties which often see significant discounts here.” – Kelly Morrow, MS, RDN, FAND
The expansion into pantry, dairy, and meat is a significant advantage.
Pantry: Impressive selection, including popular brands (e.g., Bob’s Red Mill, Kind Bars, Kettle Chips) often at noticeable discounts, alongside Misfits’ own decent private label. Great for discovering new snacks or stocking up on staples like pasta, oils, and coffee.
Meat/Dairy: Selection varied weekly but included basics like chicken breast, ground beef, bacon, milk, cheese, and yogurt. Quality was comparable to standard supermarket brands. Date codes were generally good, but always worth checking upon arrival, especially for shorter-dated surplus items.
Limitations: Don’t expect the exhaustive range of a large supermarket. Specific brands or niche items might not be available. Availability fluctuates based on surplus deals.
3. Cost Analysis: Does Misfits Market Really Save You Money? (Rating: 8.5/10)
Yes, but savings vary significantly by item category.
Item Category
Average Misfits Price
Average Supermarket Price
Average Savings
Notes
Organic Produce
$2.80 / unit/lb
$4.20 / unit/lb
~33%
Consistently strong savings
Conventional Produce
$1.90 / unit/lb
$2.50 / unit/lb
~24%
Good savings, sometimes less dramatic
Pantry Staples
$3.50 / item
$4.50 / item
~22%
Varies by brand; best on surplus deals
Meat & Dairy
$5.50 / item/lb
$6.50 / item/lb
~15%
Moderate savings, selection dependent
Overall Basket
$60.00 (excl. ship)
$76.80
~22%
Based on our average 12 test orders
Key Findings:
Highest Savings: Organic produce consistently offered the best value compared to supermarket prices. Pantry items, especially snacks and coffee, also showed significant discounts.
Factor in Fees: Remember to add the $6.99 shipping fee and ensure you meet the $40 minimum. The true savings percentage decreases on smaller orders. Maximum value is achieved on larger orders ($70+) heavily weighted towards organic produce and pantry deals.
Comparable Items: Savings on conventional produce, meat, and dairy were less dramatic but still present.
Pro Tip: Maximize value by strategically building your cart. Focus on high-saving categories like organic produce and check the ‘Deals’ section for limited-time pantry/snack offers. Avoid filling your cart with items only marginally cheaper than your local store just to hit the minimum.
4. Delivery & Customer Service: The Logistics Test (Rating: 8/10)
Packaging: Generally excellent. Insulated liners and appropriately sized ice packs kept perishables cold during transit (tested across various ambient temperatures). Most packaging components were curbside recyclable or clearly marked for specialized recycling.
Timeliness: 11 out of 12 orders arrived within the designated delivery day. One order was delayed by 24 hours due to a carrier issue (tracking was updated).
Customer Service: We tested CS with claims for the three poor-quality produce items. Responses via their online contact form came within 12-24 hours. Refunds were processed quickly (within 48 hours) back to the original payment method, no photos required in our cases, just a description of the issue. The process was hassle-free.
Misfits Market: At a Glance
What It Is: Online grocer selling imperfect/surplus produce, pantry items, meat, dairy & more.
How It Works: Free membership, customizable weekly orders, ~$40 minimum, $6.99 shipping.
Key Benefit: Significant cost savings (avg. ~20-30%) esp. on organic produce & pantry. Reduces food waste.3
Potential Drawbacks: Variable produce appearance, fluctuating inventory, requires meeting order minimum + shipping fee.
Perfectionists: If cosmetic flaws on produce are a deal-breaker.
Specific List Shoppers: Those needing exact items/brands every single week.
Very Small Households: May struggle to consistently meet the order minimum without overbuying.
Those Needing Immediate Groceries: Requires planning around delivery days.
Final Verdict & Rating: Is Misfits Market Worth It?
Overall Rating: 8.2 / 10
After extensive testing, Misfits Market proves to be a legitimate and valuable service that largely delivers on its promises. The cost savings are real, particularly for organic produce and pantry staples, consistently reaching 20-30% below supermarket prices in our tests when factoring in typical order sizes. The convenience is undeniable, and the mission to reduce food waste adds a compelling ethical dimension.
The “misfit” nature of the produce is mostly cosmetic and rarely impacts quality.4 While occasional duds occur, responsive customer service mitigates this risk. The key is understanding the model: embrace imperfection, plan your orders to meet the minimum efficiently, and focus on high-saving categories.5
It’s not a perfect replacement for all grocery needs for everyone – inventory fluctuates, and you need to accept visual quirks. But for budget-conscious, eco-aware consumers seeking convenience and savings on quality food, Misfits Market offers substantial value and is highly recommended.
No, they offer both conventional and organic items clearly labeled.
Can I skip weeks?
Yes, easily through your online account with no penalty. You are never forced to receive an order.
What if I receive a bad item?
Contact customer service through their website/app. In our experience, they issue refunds quickly for unsatisfactory items.
Is the packaging recyclable?
Mostly yes. Boxes are cardboard, liners are often recyclable plastic film, and ice packs can sometimes be drained and recycled (check local guidelines).
How does Misfits Market compare to a CSA?
Misfits is fully customizable (you pick every item), whereas CSAs typically provide a pre-selected share of the farm’s harvest.
Our experts vigilantly monitor the domain of health and wellness, promptly refreshing our articles with the latest discoveries. Your well-being is significant to us, and we stand ready to ensure you stay well-informed.
June 12, 2025
Current Version
June 12, 2025
June 12, 2025
Written By Kalpna Anand, Ph.D. Edited By Suzanne Briggs Medically Reviewed By Dr Emma Thomas, MPH, PhD Copy Edited By David Lopez-Kopp
June 12, 2025
At Body Freedom, we rely solely on top-tier sources, such as peer-reviewed studies, to bolster the veracity of our content. Dive into our editorial approach to discover how we ensure the precision, dependability, and integrity of our information.
Raftery, S., & Miner, R. (2012). Food Waste To Energy To Food. Waste Management, 163, 135-144. https://doi.org/10.2495/WM120131. ↩︎
Corvo, P. (2019). Food Waste and Quality of Life. Brexit und der Finanzmarkt. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-06022-0_15. ↩︎
Çoşan, D., & Aymankuy, Ş. (2023). Industrial use of food waste. Journal of Tourism Leisure and Hospitality. https://doi.org/10.48119/toleho.1263153. ↩︎
Johansson, K. (2016). What is the problem with food waste. . ↩︎
